Sunday, October 27, 2013

Multiverse bubbles are now all burst by the math of Nature


Steven Weinberg commented on the issue of the multiverse (at http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2013/nov/07/physics-what-we-do-and-dont-know/ ). He wrote, “Inflation is naturally chaotic. Bubbles form in the expanding universe, each developing into a big or small bang, perhaps each with different values for what we usually call the constants of nature. The inhabitants (if any) of one bubble cannot observe other bubbles, so to them their bubble appears as the whole universe. The whole assembly of all these universes has come to be called the multiverse. ... Such crude anthropic explanations are not what we have hoped for in physics, but they may have to content us.”


Per Weinberg’s definition, the bubbles are distinguished by the different nature constants which they carry. Now, let’s discuss two bubbles only.
a.       The bubble (us)  has three well-defined nature constants [e (electric charge), c (light speed) and ħ (Planck constant)]. Then, these three constants are locked with a pure number, the Alpha.
b.      The bubble (A)  has some different nature constants [d, f, g and more], and we do not know anything about these constants. It might also be locked in some way, or might be not. If it does, we can also call it the Alpha [bubble (A)].


Thus, the Alpha should be a function of Alpha (bubble x) = Alpha [something (some nature constants perhaps), bubble-specific factors]. That is, Alpha must be bubble dependent according to Weinberg’s definition.


For the Alpha [bubble (us)], it is a lock which locks three bubble (us)-nature-constants. Yet, if we can show that the Alpha [bubble (us)]-equation is completely independent of any bubble (us)-factor, then it should be a bubble-independent parameter (a universal parameter for bubble (us)).


I have shown that the Alpha (bubble (us))-equation as follow.

Beta = 1/alpha = 64 ( 1 + first order mixing + sum of the higher order mixing)
         = 64 (1 + 1/Cos A(2) + .00065737 + …)
         =  137.0359 …

 A(2) is the Weinberg angle, A(2) = 28.743 degrees

 The sum of the higher order mixing = 2(1/48)[(1/64) + (1/2)(1/64)^2 + ...+(1/n)(1/64)^n +...]
       = .00065737 + … 


This Alpha equation is dominated by the number (48 and 64) and the Weinberg angle. If these three numbers are bubble independent, then the Alpha (bubble (us)) is a universal parameter for all bubbles.




First, I would like to ask a question which has two parts.

Is math the human construct and only as the *tool* for describing the laws of Nature? Or, the laws of Nature are embedded in math?


If all laws of nature (physics) are embedded in math, and all laws of nature (including the nature constants) are the direct consequence of math, then the *Inflation chaos* can only make bubbles but not *different kind of* bubbles. Thus, the way to examine the multiverse-hypothesis is hinged on the fact whether we can *derive* all known (including the unknown) laws of Nature from *math* or not. 


As the math universe is *infinite* while the nature universe is finite, this task becomes concretizing infinities (the countable and the uncountable). In the book “Linguistics Manifesto (ISBN 978-3-8383-9722-1)”, it shows two concretizing processes.


One, embedding the countable infinite in finite --- this is done by trisecting an (any) angle. The following is quoted from that book.

If a thing "TA" is the product of an infinity to finite transformation, then TA is the concrete representation of that infinity. Can we find such a TA?

If such a TA does exist, it must be produced with "infinite" steps. Then TA and infinity (TA) are two sides of the same coin. That is,
From TA, we get infinity (TA)
From infinity (TA), we get TA.

In mathematics, there are two kinds of infinity, countable and uncountable. There is a commonly accept belief that there is no way to trisect an angle in Euclidean geometry. In fact, if we can evenly divide an angle, we can always trisect that same angle with the following process.
Divide angle A evenly.
Divide the two angles evenly again.
The top and the bottom angles are now 1/4 of A. As they are symmetrical, we will look the top angle AT only.
The middle angles are divided evenly again. They become 1/8 of A.
Let AT plus 1/8 A, and it is larger than 1/3 A.
Divide the 1/8 A evenly again, 1/16 A.
Let AT (1/4 + 1/8) minus 1/16 A. "AT" is now smaller than 1/3 A.
the above process goes countable steps.
Then, AT = 1/2 - 1/4 + 1/8 - 1/16 + 1/32 - 1/64 + 1/128 - 1/256 + 1/512 - 1/1024 + 1/2048 -... +...
= .33349 - ... + ... = .3333333333333..... = 1/3


With countable steps, the above process trisects the angle A "exactly". That is,
with countable infinity, we get AT. With AT, we get countable infinity.


With the above trisecting angle procedure, we know that 1/3 = 0.333333..., that is, 1/3 has a countable number of digits. In mathematics, we do know that the number pi (=3.14159...) is a normal number, that is, it has an uncountable number of digits in it. Then, how can we reach pi (precisely)? Well, we can reach it with the following equation.

(The circumference of a circle with a radius of 1/8) = 1 - 1/3 + 1/5 - 1/7 + 1/9 - 1/11 + 1/13 - ... + ... (with "countable" infinite steps)
= pi / 4

That is, the number pi (which contains an uncountable number of digits) is reached with a "countable" steps. So, the uncountable infinity can be renormalized with countable infinity, and countable infinity can be renormalized with the trisecting angle procedure.

Note 1: There is something interesting in equation A. The circumference of a circle with a radius of 1/8 (with an even number denominator) can be reached only with a sequence of odd number denominators.

Note 2: The area of this circle = pi / 64; then, the number "64" must be fundamental for this uncountable infinity renormalization process.


In the two equations above, the countable is concretized as a trisected angle, and the uncountable is concretized as a pie (with a radius of 1/8). These two concretizations are in fact the creation process (from infinities to finites), and it depends on two very important numbers [3 (or 1/3), 64 (or 4^3)]. Yet, these are the numbers for the Alpha-equation above. The “Theoretical calculation of Cabibbo and Weinberg angles (http://prebabel.blogspot.com/2011/10/theoretical-calculation-of-cabibbo-and.html )” is also the direct consequence of the *trisected angle* and *the division of the pie (pi)*. That is, the
Alpha (bubble (us)) is not bubble dependent but is derived from a universal *concretization* process.


The definition of a bubble is that two bubbles must not have any connection. If there is a connection between two bubbles, they are in fact a single bubble. Thus, as soon as we show that Alpha [bubble (us)]-equation is bubble-independent, there is no need for us to content with the bubble(s) issue anymore. The concretization in the Nature math is indeed fulfilling a *mission* of bubble-busting. Thus, the multiverse-hypothesis is wrong. Furthermore, the physics underneath this Alpha-equation must be fundamental for all laws of physics. This truth sits here silently, blocking all detour attempts. 


The above approach is significantly different from the current paradigm. The major difference is about the view on *MATH*. In the past 500 years, the Math was viewed as a human construct. Every great mathematician in the past created a set of lego pieces and built some great artistic wonderful structures. Yet, incidentally, many of these artificial structures are great *tools* for describing the laws of nature. This view was the history and cannot be arguing against. But, my view on math goes beyond that. That is, the physical universe is only a *subset* of the math universe, and all laws of physics (nature) can only be the emergent of laws of math. So, all known laws of physics (nature) must be directly *derived* from the laws of math, and all unknown laws of physics must also be derived from the *pure math*. Of course, if I cannot actually show the *derivations* of those laws from pure math, it will just be a personal opinion (simply nonsense). But, I have shown the calculations of the Cabibbo/Weinberg angles and Alpha. I also showed the calculations for dark mass and dark energy [DARK ENERGY, MYSTERY NO MORE! (http://tienzengong.wordpress.com/2013/09/25/dark-energy-mystery-no-more/ )] and the string unification. I think that these are enough as appetizers. Investigating the *physics* underneath those appetizers is much easier than building a new collider while I personally do support for building a new collider.


My project has only a very few step.
i.                     Concretizing the infinities (both countable and uncountable) with *physical* processes (the trisecting an angle and *dividing a pie*). This concretizing process is the *creation* process, and the Alpha-equation is this creation equation, as the anchor or the lock for the process.
ii.                   Second tier concretizing process (the rising dimensions) --- this is completely different from the ultra-dimension of M-string theory. This dimension is defined with Georg Cantor’ theorem ( In the 1870s, Georg Cantor proved that every n-dimensional space can always be brought into a one-to-one correspondence with the one-dimensional line, that is, one-dimensional line can give rise to n-dimensional space. See http://prebabel.blogspot.com/2012/04/origin-of-spatial-dimensions-and.html ). The number *64* becomes (4^3). That is, 3 spatial dimensions while each carries 4-sub-dimensions; a total of 64 dimensions.  Then, these 64 dimensions are divided into two groups, 48 matter (anti-matter) dimensions and 16 vacuum dimensions (the dark energy). Yet, with the inter-dependent relations, these 64 dimensions are reduced to 11 dimensions [7 colors (packed and hidden) and 4 expressed].


This 4-sub-dimensions form a higher symmetry than the Standard Model symmetry, that is, the SUSY (with s-particle) is ruled out. Then, the Quantum/gravity unification and the mass-rising mechanism are truly the same issue. I have shown that the ħ (Planck constant) is, in fact, the gravitation force for the ground state of a hydrogen atom (see http://www.prequark.org/Gravity.htm which also discusses the mass-rising mechanism).


For the past 100 years, physics is very successful while *ignoring* some other obvious *facts*, the life and the math (using it only as tools). The exclusion of these two facts from the scope of physics was necessary tactically, as the laws of physics are, thus far, seemingly unable to encompass them two. But, by excluding them in *principle* (such as using Boltzmann Brain as a possible cause for the rising of life), physicists are then fooling themselves, as this Nature consists of, at least, three parts.
a. The physical universe (not including life),
b. Lives,
c. Numbers.

Then, there are two possibilities. There are three different sets of laws for these three parts. Or, those three are governed with a set of unified laws.  For the current physics paradigm, it has chosen the former. On the other hand, I have selected the later (they are unified). With this choice, the other two facts (lives and numbers) become the *checkpoints* for forming the physics theory.


Life has two very important attributes, the individuality and the need of processing information (needing a computing device). Thus, a physics theory which gives rise to life must encompass,
i.                     A four-color system (red, yellow, blue, white) or (A, G, T, C) which gives rise to individuality.
ii.                   A computing device --- abacus, counting straws or a Turing machine.


Numbers encompass infinities (countable and uncountable). Thus, a physics theory must also encompass those infinities (in a concretized form, at least), not just cut-them-off by using the renormalization.


With the above view, now we have two types of physics.
A. Human physics --- physics laws *discovered* by the human.
B. Nature physics --- physics laws created by Nature.

These two types of physics are significantly different in the aspect of the emerging processes. The human physics comes about in piecemeal. The Nature physics must come as an axiomatic system expression, that is, the axiomatic physics (see http://prebabel.blogspot.com/2012/04/axiomatic-physics-final-physics.html ). This axiomatic physics goes way beyond some numbers. I have used some numbers (the Cabibbo and Weinberg angles, Alpha and Planck data) as the showcases for it, because there is no arguing about whether we have matched those numbers or not.


On the same token, there are two types of math.
C. The math of Nature --- giving rise to a physical universe (concretizing the infinities).
D. The math of human --- inventing some lego pieces and building some wonderful lego structures.


Today, the math is very much different from the physics. The validity of math needs not be verified by any *external* physical reality, that is, it is in fact de-linked from the physical universe in principle although it is the best *tool* for describing the laws of the physical universe. So, my questions are:

a. Is the math we know of today (human math) mainly the human construct (as the lego games)?
b. Is the human math the re-discovery of the Nature math, similar to the human physics which is the re-discovery of the Nature physics?
c. If there is indeed a Nature math, what is its *mission*?
d. Is the human math converging to the Nature math? Or just going all over the map, as the scope of the Nature math has infinite degree of freedom?
e. Is the Nature math governed by a set of unified laws which also govern the physical universe and life?
f. Many more.


The above questions are simple and reasonable, and they should change our view about math completely just by those questions, regardless of their answers. By choosing a *unified* view, the math becomes the *check-point* for any physics theory, and the structure of the laws of physics also must be the structure of the Nature math. The symmetry structure of the laws of physics are indeed the properties of many math structures. Steven Weinberg said, "String theory is attractive because it incorporates gravitation, it contains no infinities, ...". Yet, with this unified view, the physical universe (although totally finite) must encompass all infinities which are the essential parts of the math universe. And, this becomes a very important check-point for any physics theory. Thus, the concretization of infinities in a physics theory becomes the central point. Yet, we don’t see any such a connection between the human physics and the human math. The major problem comes from the definition of *continuity* in math, which sweep the essence of the Nature math under the carpet. The key essence of the Nature math can be expressed with one simple equation.
     A – b = 0 but A is not  b.
What does this mean?

The *numbers* are in *principle* (with some exceptions) not *reachable* by all finite *means* (arithmetic / algebra operators, etc.), such as (1/3) = .333… = .3C (C as countable digits) ;  Pi = 3.14159… = 3.14159+ (+ as uncountable digits) ; etc. . This *unreachable* fact is permeated all over the places. The simplest example is the prime numbers which are unreachable by the *multiplication* operation (see The unreachable number principle (http://tienzen.blogspot.com/2012/05/unreachable-number-principle.html ). Thus, when b being a *touching* number of A [that is, their distance (A – b) = 0], but A is not b. That is, b is unreachable by all means, and the best way to identify b is A+ or A-. Thus, the majority of numbers must be *color* coded [let, A as yellow, A- as red and A+ as blue]. Then, there are *reachable numbers* (the white).


As numbers must be a colored-system, it could be the base for the life-color system (A, G, T, C) which gives rise to individuality. In fact, life has a third attribute, the immortality which needs 3 additional codes (colors) --- G1, G2 and G3 [G1 as M (male), G2 as F (female) and G3 as K (kids)]. If we can show that the numbers are in fact a 7-color system, then the Nature math is the base for life.

In the book “Super Unified Theory (ISBN 0-916713-02-4, Copyright # TX 1-323-231, Library of Congress Catalog Card Number 84-90325)”, the entire set of laws of physics is *derived* from this Nature Math, and the half of the book is about this Nature Math.
Chapter 7 --- Colored numbers (page 53 – 61)
Chapter 8 --- Chromology (page 62 – 69), colored numbers (part 2)
Chapter 9 --- Unilogy (page 70 – 74),   *punched* topology
The Chapter 7, it gives a detailed description about numbers which are a 7-color system.


This new paradigm claims that the *mission* for the math of Nature is to derive all laws of Nature (physics). Thus, I must show at least one solid example here, in addition to the deriving of the Cabibbo / Weinberg angles and the Alpha.


Again, the essence of the math of Nature is all about infinities and the pathways of their concretization. That is, the key equation is,
A – b = 0, but A is not b.

This means that most of the numbers are unreachable by finite means (arithmetic and algebra operations), as every *finite* number is the concretization of infinities (either countable or uncountable), and it does carry a tail with infinite digits. That is, for any selected number *A*, it is surrounded by zillions (at least two) neighborhood numbers which are not distinguishable from the number *A* by all means. Thus, all those unreachable (indistinguishable from the number *A*) numbers must be color-coded, such as, b = A (red) or = A (blue).


Yet, there is always a number C, and
A – C > 0
The largest C cannot truly be determined with finite means. But, in principle, there is always *a* largest C in the physical universe *with* finite means. That is,
A – C = g
Although we do not know the exact value for g, g is larger than 0 (g > 0). In the math universe, g is undetermined and can approach the concept of *continuity*. Yet, in the finite (physical) universe, this g becomes the smallest *deterministic unit*, distinguishing the number *C* from the number *A*. Indeed, for the *physical* universe, the g can actually be determined. Let,
X-axis as space, thus, the (delta S > =g).
Y-axis as momentum, the (delta P >= g).
So, (delta P) x (delta S) >= g^2


In physics, the photon is the medium for causality (see Constants of Nature, http://www.prequark.org/Constant.htm ). Thus, the smallest *deterministic* unit (for causality) in the physical universe is (photon / c), c is the light speed.  That is, in the physical universe, g^2 = (photon / c).


Yet, the photon is the result of the interaction of e (electron).
So, g^2 = (photon /c) = (e^2/c), e is electric charge.
In the article “The Rise of Gravity and Electric Charge, ( http://www.prequark.org/Gravity.htm )”, the e-charge is,

e (charge) = (L * C)^(1/2) = [(1/2) ħ * C]^(1/2); L the angular momentum, C light speed, ħ (Planck constant).


So, g^2 = ħ * C / C = ħ,
Thus, (delta P) x (delta S) > = g^2 >= ħ


Now, the uncertainty principle of physics is the direct consequence of the *Nature math*, the essence of infinities and of unreachable of numbers. With this *derivation*, this new paradigm is fully verified. Yet, there is one very important additional point. That is, this major essence of the *unreachable numbers* is swept away in the human math by the concept of *continuity*. That is, the human math is completely unaware of this *Nature math*. 




The cyclic universe (C-multiverses) with different initial conditions while having the same physics laws and nature constants is the central point in the book “Super Unified Theory; ISBN 9780916713010, US Copyright number TX 1-323-231”. 

The simultaneous-coexist-multiverse (S-multiverse, with different physics laws and nature constants) is totally wrong.




Note (added on August 28, 2016):

The current (2016) mainstream physics status is this:#PostCheckmateTTF (Post Checkmate temper tantrum fit).





 Copyright © October 2013 by Tienzen (Jeh-Tween) Gong

Saturday, October 19, 2013

Silent truth, blocking all detour attempts


Henry Gee, a senior editor at Nature penned a piece entitled, “Science: the religion that must not be questioned (http://www.theguardian.com/science/occams-corner/2013/sep/19/science-religion-not-be-questioned?commentpage=1 )”. His conclusion is,  “Why is this? The answer, I think, is that those who are scientists, or who pretend to be scientists, cling to the mantle of a kind of religious authority. And as anyone who has tried to comment on religion has discovered, there is no such thing as criticism. There is only blasphemy.”


Truth sits here silently, blocking all detour attempts. Anyone who is sincerely seeking for truth must face this silently sitting truth squarely. Any those self-proclaimed religious-like authorities will simply fade away into the trash in history. The Alpha equation below is a simple truth *checkable* by every 8th grader. Yet, the physics underneath this equation sits there silently, blocking all detour attempts. No one can go over, go under or go around it.


Beta = 1/alpha = 64 ( 1 + first order mixing + sum of the higher order mixing)
         = 64 (1 + 1/Cos A(2) + .00065737 + …)
         =  137.0359 …

 A(2) is the Weinberg angle, A(2) = 28.743 degrees

 The sum of the higher order mixing = 2(1/48)[(1/64) + (1/2)(1/64)^2 + ...+(1/n)(1/64)^n +...]
       = .00065737 + … 


Yet, In Wikipedia today (October 19, 2013), it makes two points about the Alpha [α (electron fine structure constant),  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fine-structure_constant  ].

a.       It was called the greatest damn mysteries of physics by Richard Feynman, and it still is as it cannot be derived from any physics theory or equations.
b.      It showed a numerological formula for it.

For the worst, the Wikipedia should include my Alpha equation as a numerological formula, but it does not. Perhaps, it is unknown to anyone. But, it was published in Professor Matt Strassler's blog (http://profmattstrassler.com/2012/02/23/synopsis-of-the-opera-situation/#comment-6531 ), a very popular physics discussion site, and at
http://blog.vixra.org/2013/05/16/why-i-still-like-string-theory/#comment-32568 , another very popular physics blog. And it is available at many other places; a partial list is listed below.



Obviously, this is caused by the “worried,” “discouraged,” and “scared” (the WDS) mentality, and I made a comment (http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2013/10/14/inside-the-mind-of-the-republican-party/#comment-7295910552604272743 ) as below.

Indeed, “worried,” “discouraged,” and “scared” (the WDS) can make a group people going berserk, and this small group can then make the entire country going craze --- “The demographics are tending strongly against what we now think of as the Republican base. The world is changing, and they don’t like it.” … But, I have a similar question. Can this WDS infiltrate science, such as physics? That is, is a verified scientific fact (or easily verifiable fact) still not a truth until it is *ordained* by the current paradigm (because of this WDS)? 


Furthermore, not facing the above simple fact will not alleviate us from our nightmare situation.  

a.       In the article “What *Should* We Be Worried About? (http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=5465 ), the Higgs connotes a great crisis of physics.
b.      Jester (Résonaances, http://resonaances.blogspot.com/2013/08/what-about-b-to-k-star-mu-mu.html ) showed his trademark pessimism and frustration.
c.       In the article “the crisis in modern physics, (http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=6238 ), Turok (Director of Perimeter Institute) said, "Theoretical physics is at a crossroads [after the Higgs] right now…In a sense, we’ve entered a very deep crisis.


The nightmare above connotes a dead end for the Standard Model. Yet, this crisis is not truly serious according to the article “Top Ten Higgs Boson Facts (by Sean Carroll, at http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2012/11/13/top-ten-amazing-higgs-boson-facts/ )”. Three its facts are as below.
(6.) The Higgs boson isn’t really all that important.
(8.) Your own mass doesn’t come from the Higgs.
(10.) The easy part is over --- The discovery of the Higgs …  leaves plenty of physics that we don’t yet understand, from dark matter to the origin of the universe, not to mention complicated problems like turbulence and neuroscience and politics.

Indeed, the new era is defined by dark mass and the dark energy which requires a conceptual revolution in physics. One possible revolution is about the mass-charge which gives our own mass. This mass-charge is described in a Pimple model. The details of this model is available at




Truth sits here silently, blocking all detour attempts. No one can go over, go under or go around it. 





Friday, August 2, 2013

Dark matter, mystery no more, part 2!



Theoretical Physicist, Professor Matt Strassler, recently described that SUSY (with s-particle) is a purely speculative idea.  Luboš Motl (a physics blogger) wrote a negative comment about Matt’s usage of the word “speculation”: “Matt's adjective "speculative" makes SUSY – and all BSM physics research – sound like a speculative, philosophical, futuristic research or a research of unhinged crackpots. It's none of these things. … Supersymmetry is primarily a symmetry whose restoration seems inevitable at the Planck scale or lower in consistent theories of quantum gravity. It is also a symmetry that produces the most natural dark-matter candidates we know in literature.”


I strongly agree with Matt’s usage of that word. So, I wrote two comments on his blog (http://profmattstrassler.com/2013/07/31/a-few-stories-worth-a-comment/#comment-71566 ). The following is a rewrite of those comments which strongly refute Motl’s points.


First, we should examine what SUSY (with s-particle) is all about.


Let one ball (perfect sphere) rotating on its center and a very fine laser beam hits the ball while the beam reflects on a screen. During the rotation, if the laser dot on the screen does not move, then all those points which are swept by the beam are symmetrical somehow.


a. For a perfect ball, the laser dot on the screen will never move. This can be described in two ways,
      i. infinite degree of symmetry,
      ii. zero (0) point symmetry break.


b. If that perfect ball is punched and has a needle-hole, then we can find, at least, one occasion that the laser dot will move. That is, the infinite degree of symmetry is no more, and there is at least one (1) symmetry break.


c. If a few ditches are scratched on the ball surface (forming a soccer ball like pattern), we will notice that the “symmetry break” increases. That is, we will conclude that more patches on the ball the lesser degrees of symmetry.


For the Standard Model, it has 48 elementary particles which can be described as a (4 x 4 x 3) cube. And, this cube can be represented as a patched ball. If these 48 particles can be represented by a code of (3 x 3 x 2) cube, then this new cube has higher degrees of symmetry. On the other hand, if we double the 48 to 96, then the degrees of symmetry will be reduced.


With this understanding, no one can see that the SUSY (with s-particle) can be a higher symmetry. It should be a lower symmetry.


If this SUSY (s-particle) is not placed on the original ball but is on a new ball, then the entire system becomes a dumbbell which has very low symmetry from any “stand-point”.  In fact, there is no way to convince anyone that SUSY (with s-particle) has higher degrees of symmetry than without it. If SUSY (s-particle) is not a higher symmetry, then what are all the hypes about it?


Second, can we refute Motl’s comment that SUSY (with s-particles) is absolutely necessary for the issues of dark-matter and hierarchy problem? This issue can be discussed clearly with a grandmother/boy dialogue.


Boy: grandmother, someone says that SUSY (with s-particles) is absolutely needed for dark-matter and the hierarchy problem. If the soccer-ball/laser-beam model cannot address these two issues, it must be wrong.


Grandmother: Exactly. The dark matter is about (5.8571428 – w) times the visible matter from this soccer-ball “calculation”.


Boy: Planck data is now public, and it shows (25.8/4.82) = 5.3526 times. Are you just making one up with this known data? By the way, I am not good at math at all. Thus, any complicate calculation will definitely go over my head. Just tell me some reasons behind the calculation.


Grandmother: No, not complicate calculation, just counting fingers. But, we first must get the “language” correct, a linguistic issue, you know.
     B = baryongenesis (matter/anti-matter symmetry-breaking)

Which one (A or B) has higher “degrees” of symmetry?


Boy: Come on! Of course, A has higher degrees of symmetry.


Grandmother: Indeed, this is “the” problem. Boy, you are wrong. Please see the following points.
     a. If the ball is a “perfect” sphere, the laser dot will not move forever. Thus, it has “infinite” degrees of symmetry.

     b. If there is one pin-hole on the ball, the laser dot will “eventually” make a jump (symmetry break). However big this “eventually” is, it is finite. So, it has much fewer degrees of symmetry than the first case.

     c. If there are 24 pin-holes (patches) on the ball, the laser dot will jump (symmetry break) Y-times.

     d. If there are 48 pin-holes (patches) on the ball, the laser dot will jump (symmetry break) Z-times.   

It is very obvious that Z is larger than Y. Thus, the case c has higher “degrees” of symmetry than the case d. So, B (baryongenesis) must have higher degrees of symmetry than A (matter/anti-matter symmetry).


Boy: So what! What the heck is symmetry good for anyway! Why should it become a big deal, especially for the nature laws?


Grandmother: All is about the laziness. For example, there are 81 equations in the multiplication table. But, 5 x 8 = 8 x 5, thus, we need only memorize one-half (about 40) of these equations. So, symmetry is all about memory-management; the higher the symmetry, the lesser the memory-energy is needed. The universe is very huge and complicated while the Nature is very lazy. So, Nature plays this symmetry game, as it needs only to hold on one leash to control all. You kids can roam free but must obey the symmetrical rules. So, nature’s kids went out the world which is demarcated with many symmetrical-ditches.


Boy: Okay, okay. So, the ball is demarcated with symmetrical-ditches. What does this get to do with the dark-matter?


Grandmother: In order to increase the degrees of symmetry (tighten the leash), many ditches are filled while the lands are still owned by the symmetry-claimers. So, the laser dot will not move when it goes over those demarcations. That is, those lands become “dark-lands”, no laser-jumps (no manifested “particles [or ditches]”). Yet, while they turn dark (not manifested as particles), they still take up the land, still having the landmass, no difference from the visible particles in terms of the landmass. For the 48 SM particle-land-patches, 40 of them are dark-lands. Electron-neutrino is also dark. So, the total dark-lands are 41, that is, the dark/visible ratio is [(41/7 = 5.8571428) – w].


Boy: Why “-w”?


Grandmother: The playing of these visible-kids is often getting out-of-the-bound into the dark-lands, and it causes some sparks there. According to the AMS-2 data, the out-of-the-bound sparks account for (8 to 10%) of the dark-landmass. Thus, [41 x (100 – 9) % /7 = 5.3300] is almost identical to the Planck data [(25.8/4.82) = 5.3526].


Boy: Wow! You are really lucky and can make up numbers.


Grandmother: Well, the Alpha equation uses the same soccer-ball calculation.


Boy: How about the hierarchy problem?


Grandmother: Not today. But, there are no “fundamental” particles beyond the SM 48 particles on this soccer-ball, from here all the way to “the … energy”. Furthermore, the “infinite” degrees to “finite” degrees are a much bigger jump than the hierarchy problem.




Friday, June 21, 2013

G-string, the final nail seals the Higgs coffin



{Note (added on April 2, 2015, months before the LHC run II):

There should be a vacuum boson {as vacuum [d (blue), -d (-yellow)] quark pair} transformed into vacuum {u (yellow), -u (-blue)}, see http://www.prequark.org/pq11.htm (no longer online).


This vacuum boson's mass should be:

{Vacuum energy (about 246 Gev) divided by 2} + {a push over energy (vacuum fluctuation, about 2.46 Gev)}
= 123 + 2.46 = 125.46 Gev.

The above calculation has only one parameter: the vacuum energy. As a vacuum boson, its key feature is having a zero (0) spin.


Three years after the discovery of this new 125.4 Gev boson, the Higgs mechanism is not verified (see the article from Nigel Lockyer, Director of Fermi Lab. at http://www.quantumdiaries.org/2014/04/24/massive-thoughts/ ). That is, the Higgs mechanism is wrong, total nonsense, and of course, there is no Higgs boson; it is a Vacuum Boson.
Endnote.}




In the article (http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=6002 ), Peter Woit wrote, “…  since the story of the last thirty years is not one of evidence for string  [M-] theory unification accumulating, but the opposite: the more we learn about string [M-] theory, the less likely it seems that it can predict anything.  …
String [M-] theory unification is an idea now discredited in the scientific community, but getting propped up by TV programs and prizes from Russian billionaires. …
I actually know many people who work on string theory who have given up on the idea of getting the Standard Model out of it. The most common attitude I hear among string theorists is that the ways people used to hope to connect it to the SM have failed."


In fact, there is a litmus test to settle the above debate. Einstein said, “You do not really understand something unless you can explain it to your grandmother”.  In addition to simply agree with Einstein 100%, I would like to give it a theoretical support with the following points.


A. Whatever the “foundation” of this universe is, this universe evolves via the self-similarity transformation from that foundation. However complicated a “physics law” is, it is always only a “foundation” of the higher tier manifestations. That is, the essence of that physics law is expressed in every piece of the higher tier “expression”. If we cannot use a “story” which is easily understood by the old grandmother, we did not truly understand that complicated physics law, period.


B.  In general, people view the linguistics as languages. I will define the linguistics universe with three parts.
a. A meta-space --- it encompasses the events and objects in the physical universe.

b. Languages --- they try to describe the stories in that meta-space.

c. A meaning-space --- the meaning of the meta-space story is understood by people.


In general, a meta-space story could be understood differently by different people who have different worldviews. However, we could exclude the culture element and deal the issue strictly linguistically, that is, in terms of translation among languages only. Then, the meaning-space for all languages is identical.


Now, for all languages (including mathematics), they share two identical continents (meta-space and meaning-space). That is, “all” languages are permanently linked among one another by these two continents. And, every language can be “translated” to any other language. Math is the “simplest” language in linguistics. When one cannot translate a math equation into a natural language, he does for sure not truly understand that math equation.


Now, the true “solid” facts in physics are,



If we can show these two facts to the old grandmother, we have understood the essences of these two physics facts. The following is the explanation.


Grandmother, this universe is very simple, just the same as an amphitheater which has 4 parts.
1. It sits in a big “field” (open space, dark energy ).
2. It has an audiences section (not shining, dark mass).
3. It has a stage (for actors, visible mass).
4. It has a backstage (for directors, screenplay writers, etc.; anti-matter)


The open field carries a tremendous amount of dark energy. The chairs in all section(s) carry a lot of dark mass. Of course, there are three types of chairs (L1, L2, L3), one for each “section”. Every chair is made of a piece of tree trunk (a line-string, that is).  A line-string has three parts, the two ends and one middle section which connects the two ends. Thus, the three parts of this line-string are distinguishable and can be written as (a, b, c) in mathematical symbols. Yet, there is a special property of this line-string. When its two ends join together, its three parts are no longer distinguishable. It works just like following the “color rules”. Thus, I will use (red, yellow, blue) or (r, y, b) to replace the old (a, b, c) symbol. So, every piece of tree trunk (line-string) can sit three audiences, three actors or three directors, etc..


Now, we have an empty amphitheater. With some “people” come in, it will come alive. And, its liveliness (dynamics) can be described with some formulas. Let’s use,
i. A (audience, actor; as a person)
ii. V (vacant seat)


So, by knowing the seating situations, we can calculate the entire dynamics of the theater. Of course, every person who comes in needs pay a “charge”. As he sits on only 1/3 of the tree trunk, he pays only 1/3 of “charge”. The status of every chair (tree trunk) can be identified with a color system. After “A” occupies a seat, that seat color is blocked (A being opaque). Of course, V (being a vacant seat) is transparent. Now, the status of the seating situation can be identified with the following system.

      1. (V, V, V) = (r, y, b) = white = colorless, as V is transparent.
      2. (A, A, A) = colorless = white, as A is opaque.
      3. (V, A, A) = (r, A, A) = red;  (A, V, A) = yellow;  (A, A, V) = blue
      4, (V, V, A) = (r, y, A) = blue (complement of r + Y)


With the above, we can identify “all” possible seating situation in the theater. Just for the fun, I will call a tree trunk as G-string and give some funny names (no special meaning to them) for those different types of sitting situation as below.


String 1 =  (V,  A,  A 1) = {1st , red, 2/3 e, ½ ħ} = red up quark.
String 2 =  (A,  V, V  1) = {1st , red, 1/3 e, ½ ħ} = red anti-down quark.
String 3 =  (A,  A, V  1) =  {1st , blue, 2/3 e, ½ ħ} = blue up quark.
…
String 7 = (A, A, A 1) = {1st, white (colorless), 1 e, ½ ħ} = e (electron).
String 8 = (V, V, V 1) = {1st, white, 0 e, ½ ħ} = e-neutrino.
String 9 = (V,  A,  A 2) {2nd  , red, 2/3 e, ½ ħ} = red charm quark.
…
String 48 = -(V, V, V 3)  - {3rd, white, 0 e, ½ ħ} = anti-tau-neutrino.


Not only is this description of an amphitheater (the G-strings) definitely understood by the old grandmother, but it has accomplished the task of getting the SM (Standard Model) out, which was an impossible task for the M-string theory for over 40 years.




This amphitheater model also provides the calculation for Planck CMB data 1: (dark energy = 69.2; dark matter = 25.8; and visible matter = 4.82)

Seven (7) G1 strings are the actors on stages, visible mass.
The e-neutrino, G2, G3 strings (total 17) are audience, dark mass 1.
The anti-matters (total 24) are on the backstage (directors), dark mass 2.

So, the d/v (dark/visible ratio) = [41 (100 – W) % / 7]

When, W = 9 % (the dark radiation, the ratio of dark mass melting into dark energy), d/v = 5.33

[(Z – V) x (100 – W) %] /5.33 = V, V is visible mass of this universe; Z = (1/3).

[(33.33 –V) x .91]/5.33 = V

V= 5.69048 / 1.17073 = 4.86   (while the Planck data is 4.82),

D (Dark mass) = [(Z – 4.86) x (100 – W) %] = [(33.33 -4.86) x .91] = 25.90 (while the Planck data = 25.8)

See, https://tienzengong.wordpress.com/2015/04/22/dark-energydark-mass-the-silent-truth/ for details.

By passing this grandmother test, the G-string is definitely a foundation for the Standard Model. Yet, the G-string rules out the Higgs hallucination (see http://prebabel.blogspot.com/2013/06/higgs-chicken-higgs-egg-and-higgs.html ) and is the last nail on Higgs coffin.

Thursday, June 13, 2013

Higgs chicken, Higgs egg and Higgs hallucination


{Note (added on April 2, 2015, months before the LHC run II):

There should be a vacuum boson {as vacuum [d (blue), -d (-yellow)] quark pair} transformed into vacuum {u (yellow), -u (-blue)}, see http://www.prequark.org/pq11.htm (no longer online).


This vacuum boson's mass should be:

{Vacuum energy (about 246 Gev) divided by 2} + {a push over energy (vacuum fluctuation, about 2.46 Gev)}
= 123 + 2.46 = 125.46 Gev.

The above calculation has only one parameter: the vacuum energy. As a vacuum boson, its key feature is having a zero (0) spin.


Three years after the discovery of this new 125.4 Gev boson, the Higgs mechanism is not verified (see an article from Nigel Lockyer, Director of Fermi Lab. at http://www.quantumdiaries.org/2014/04/24/massive-thoughts/ ). That is, the Higgs mechanism is wrong, total nonsense, and of course, there is no Higgs boson; it is a Vacuum Boson.
Endnote.}




After the discovery of a 125 Gev boson last July (2012) at LHC, it is now called as Higgs boson by all presentations which discuss that new particle. Thus, I must show that the Higgs hallucination is simply fairy tales with the following stories, as there is a good another model available.


Story one:
Mother: Hi, baby, it is the time to hit the sack.

Baby: I am still working on my homework, the neutron decay. How can a three string particle (u, d, d) become 5 strings (u, u, d, e, anti-e-neutrino), especially a “d” had a sex-change for becoming a “u”?


Mother: This is the most famous fairy tale. Here comes an angel who gave the “d” a kick on its butt, and it comes the “u”.


Baby: Who is the angel?


Mother: Who? Who?  The “W”.


Baby: Then, where are this e and the neutrino coming from?


Mother: Oh. The “W” angel flies away as the e and the neutrino.


Baby: Where was the “W” angel coming from?


Mother: There is a Higgs chicken (field) which is omnipresent, and it can lay a Higgs egg anywhere at any time of its choosing. The “W” angel was hiding in the Higgs egg all this time.


Baby: Thanks, Mon. This is a great fairy tale. I now can sleep in peace.


Story two:
Brother: Mon, your fairy tale is very interesting. But, I learned a different story about the neutron decay.


Mother: There cannot be any different story. This fairy tale is the “Standard Model”. But, go ahead tell me your story.

Brother: Every system consists of three parts.
i. An envelope which divides it into two regions.
ii. The “internal” --- with some members, having some relationships among them (the dynamics)
iii. The “external” --- with a sea of …

For the convenience, we call these members as “chairs” which the dynamics as “music-chair game”. And, the external sea is expressed as a sea of (virtue) chairs.


When one of the internal chairs is captured (arrested) by external (virtue) chairs, the system breaks up (must decay). If the external (virtue) chairs [the vacuum energy] lack the energy to arrest an internal chair of a system, that system will not decay. These can be summarized as the “Show-will-never-end” principle:  If the music-chair-game can be played forever “internally” (self-playing), the system will never decay. Otherwise, the system must open its door and let the external chairs coming, which leads the decay. With these, it is quite easy to show that Proton will not decay at the current vacuum energy level. Thus, I will only talk about the neutron decay.


Mother: Interesting concept but making sense. But, what is this got to do with the neutron decay which is wholly understood with the Higgs tale?


Brother: The Higgs hallucination is truly a fairy tale. The true process is that the (u, d1, d2) picks up a virtue d-pair (d3, -d3), the vacuum disturbance.  And it forms a 5-quark blob. Then,
Step 1: (d1, -d3) got together

Step 2: (d1, -d3) turns into (u1, -u3), that is, a vacuum state transforms into another vacuum state.

Step 3: (d3, -u3) got together. Then, this blob has a genetic exchange and flies away as the e and the neutrino.

 So, (u, d1, d2) decaies into as (u, u1, d2, e, neutrino).

Mon, you have mistaken this vacuum transformation blob as the Higgs egg.


Mother: Your story follows all physics laws, and it makes sense. But it is wrong because that it is not the Standard Model.



Story three:

Baby: I don’t like your “vacuum blob” story. It is too rational and too cold. I like the fairy tale, not because of its being the Standard Model but because that it is “Magical”. A Higgs chicken (field) is omnipresent and can lay Higgs egg any time at any place at its choosing. Then, out it pops a “W”-angel when neutron got out of from bondage. Furthermore, no gadget thus far (including the LHC) in this world is able to distinguish your “vacuum blob” from the Higgs egg. That is, that fairy egg can be as real as the “vacuum blob” reality, and there is no gadget data can prove it otherwise.


Brother: Hi, baby, for the gadget testing concern, you might be right for the next decade or two. But, in sports, any tie can be easily broken by “overtime”, the tie-break-litmus test.

The Standard Model is absolutely correct in terms of that entire gadget testing data. But, as soon as it goes out of its baby crib, SM fails from left to right, from top to bottom. It (SM) cannot derive most of the “parameters” it used in the model (such as, the Cabibbo and Weinberg angles, the Alpha, etc.). Furthermore, it fails on all the following known physics facts;

i.  Planck data --- dark energy (accelerating expansion of this universe), dark matter, Neff = 3 (minimum), etc.


iii. Proton’s stability

iv. Guidelines for SUSY (with s-particle)

v. About gravity

vi. Unification between quantum and determinism.


That is, the Standard Model is only the hodgepodge of the gadget data.  And, simply it has “no” theoretical “base” for deriving those parameters and for connecting to those other physics facts.


Thus, those other facts above become the overtime litmus tests. Anyone who can solve any one of those other facts or derive those free parameters is the winner of this contest. 


Baby: Yet, most of those issues are controversial and cannot be decided by the current gadget testing.


Brother: Indeed. But, the Cabibbo - Weinberg angles and the Alpha are only three “numbers”. The only gadgets needed for testing them are “paper and pencil” which are in the hands of every first grader. There will be absolutely no controversy about whether an equation for calculating one of them is correct or not. Thus, we can simply choose Alpha as this overtime Litmus test, to be the “first” criterion for the correct final physics.


Baby: That is great. But, verifying the “prediction” of a theory was the only criterion for physics theory thus far. How can you convince physicists to accept your overtime idea?


Brother: Most of the theory is the “extension” of known physics. Thus, it must “predict” something new in order to be credible. But, when a “system” is constructed from a “base” which contains no “known” physics of any kind, it is credible only if it can “reproduce” all known physics, not just any puny “prediction”.  That is, a system has “outcomes (or consequences)” while theory has “prediction”. And, there is a super strong requirement for “base”. It must not contain any “known physics”, that is, no known physics is “put-in” into the base. Thus, “reproduce all known physics from a base (without containing any known physics)” is the second “Overtime test”, the second criterion.


Baby: Must a base be verified by gadget testing?


Brother: No, no, and no! The “base” needs no verification. If a “wrong” base produces a system which can reproduce all known physics, it is a “good” base.


Baby: Just heard in the news that a “W”-einstein had discovered the final physics theory. Do you know anything about it?


Brother: No, never heard about it. If he can pass two tests,
a. Litmus test --- deriving the Alpha with a physics equation
b. A base is able to reproduce, at least, the known 48 elementary particles
then, he could be on the path to the final physics. Otherwise, even the “Z”-einstein won’t do any good.


Baby: Obviously, the Higgs story failed the first overtime litmus test. Can you derive Alpha from a base (without containing any known physics)?


Brother: Yet, see the article “Alpha, Fine Structure Constant, mystery no more!” at http://prebabel.blogspot.com/2012/04/alpha-fine-structure-constant-mystery.html